Friday, October 16, 2009

Should girls play football with the boys?

The other day in class Dr. Spencer asked if girls should be allowed to play football with the boys and it sparked up a pretty big debate that lasted the remainder of the class period. I am here to say that girls should not and cannot play football with boys at certain levels. Look I understand that at a peewee football level girls can probably play with boys, but when you get to high school the number of girls that could possibly play with boys decreases substantially. When you get to the college level especially division one forget about it. A male’s body is far more powerful than that of females when you talk football. Were talking people who are 6’6” 300lbs and are hitting people either at the line of scrimmage or 6’2” 250lbs. With men this size women could not take down someone of this size and being hit with that much force could easily hurt a woman pretty easily. There is also the speed factor involved with male athletes. I do not think a female could keep up in pads and helmet with a male in the same gear. I understand there is that once in a blue moon female that can maybe compete at the level such as Holly Mangold but if you look at her she is still struggling at a DII school for playing time. If you’re not starting or getting valuable minutes during the game, then I do not see what impact she could possibly have for a college team. Also there was a kicker I believe for a college team that was a female, but in my opinion and I am sure in a lot of other people’s the kicker does not count. They are not taking the beating day in and day out like the other players. I could also see some issues with injuries and potential softening of the game to compensate for women, if of course they were to play. The game of football has already changed enough to where I think it’s a little too soft and if women were to play I think the leagues would create new rules to protect players of the opposite sex. So for now let’s leave professional and college football to the men and women can still have the powder-puff leagues I hear so much about in other areas. I know with that last comment I am sure to bring some controversy, but I would love to hear it.

3 comments:

  1. Everything you said I agree with. How many women do we see that are 6'6 300 lbs? First off what women would want to look like it? There is just to much powerful men at the professional level that no women I feel could compete with them at a game of football. I would love to find a woman that would want to be hit by Ray Lewis and can take repeated shots and contuine to get up.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While you are thinking about it, how many men would be able to take continual hits from Ray Lewis? And why is that the measure that matters?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that women should be able to compete if they really want to and are physically able to. If they have the talent to play football, who says they shouldn't be able to? Holly Mangold might be an extreme example, but there are a lot of females out there they could play football. They don't necessarily have to be giants to play, look at most quarterbacks and kickers in the game. Most men couldn't take shots from Ray Lewis so I don't see how that could be a factor in whether women should play or not.

    ReplyDelete