Today I would like to discuss the issue with Caster Semenya and the gender testing issue. First off I think it was wrong to question whether or not she was male or female just because she did not fit the normal characteristics "we stereotype as a group" of a woman. Second just because she dominated the competition by a wide margin should not have created so much controversy. I never understood why if a man dominates their particular sport, there is no problem with it. The only question that might arise is if they were on performance enhancing drugs. I think if you look at someone like Usain Bolt who just beat two world records and also destroyed the competition, no one has questioned this at all. I don't think it makes any sense for someone like Usain Bolt gets away with no controversy and someone like Caster Semenya does. I kinda want to find what everyone else thinks about this subject too, so if you could post some comments it would be helpful.
I also have just found out that the test result show that she was a hermaphrodite and I must say although shocked, I am disappointed the way it was handled. Now there is plenty of trauma in her life with the recent news. I heard in my class that she is on possible suicide watch because of all the controversy she is dealing with. Now the South Africa Athletics is calling for the International Associations of Athletics Federation or IAAF to give Caster Semenya an apology for the way they handled the situation. I would like to know what everyone thinks about the latest news of her being a hermaphrodite. Do you think there should be a separate league for people born with this? What about possibly having them claim themselves either male or female and then have them compete?
Let me know what you think
Get back at me
Peace
Monday, September 14, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I definitely agree that why should a female be question if she is a guy or girl if she is dominating her field. Yes why wasn't Usain Bolt questioned for performance enhancements, not all roids make an individual bigger. The way the situation came about is no where near what i would have did. It would have been a private research/investigation. Questioning a persons gender is horrible considering a person is raised as a girl or boy.
ReplyDeleteI don't know really what do with this situation? Do you let her stay and compete with the women? That wouldn't be fair to me because she is already breaking world records so to me it would be to easy for her. But you couldn't have her compete with the men because the men are just too fast for her.
ReplyDeleteI would have to say that you let her compete in which way she was raised. You just have to make sure that she was raised as a girl and not a boy.
But what about the hormones that make her intersex?
ReplyDeleteI do not feel it was right to question her sex either. Not based off her looks anyway. But now that it was found that she is intersex I do not think she should be able to compete against women. She has more than 3 times their testosterone which means she has much more muscle build, which means alot in track and field.
ReplyDelete